
The Crested Butte News’ legal battle to ensure that libraries don’t shield users in a way that damages public transparency has come to an end. At the end of May, state legislators passed a new law codifying that users can’t request that books be removed under a cloak of anonymity.
Colorado legislators passed Senate Bill 24-216 at the end of May, which outlines a slew of protections to ensure public libraries offer a wide array of books, movies, magazines and more. It includes provisions that address the central concern in Crested Butte News’ Editor Mark Reaman’s lawsuit against Drew Brookhart, the executive director of the Gunnison County Public Library. Under the new law, the identities of people who request books be removed from the shelves are publicly available.
The case started years ago, when a Gunnison Valley resident requested that the book “Gender Queer” by Maia Kobabe, a graphic memoir that includes themes of sexuality, be removed or reclassified to the adult section. At a contentious and well-attended library board meeting, library board members chose to keep the book. Reaman then filed an open records request for the “Request for Reconsideration Materials” form — submitted to remove or reclassify any library materials.
“I felt that if you are trying to prohibit use of something in the library, that you are not a user of the library just because you filed a form. I was really not happy that you could do it anonymously,” Reaman said. “That’s how democracy is supposed to work. You can debate. You can argue, but you need to do it in public.”
The library released the form to CB News. As a result, the resident who tried to have the book removed sought criminal charges against Brookhart, alleging he had violated her right to privacy as a library user. But the District Attorney’s office declined to press charges. Brookhart then went to district court seeking clarification about the protections offered to library “users” under state statute. More specifically, if the forms can be requested under Colorado Open Records Act (CORA) laws.
Former district court judge J. Steven Patrick ruled that the forms were discoverable under CORA, but that library user privacy laws required information that could be used to identify the individual to be redacted. Reaman then went to the state court of appeals, with the Gunnison County Library’s support, asking the three-judge panel to overturn the decision and rule that that information should be public.
In October of 2023, the court of appeals upheld Patrick’s ruling, concluding that individuals who request the removal of library books are considered library users and their identity could be shielded. Reaman’s lawyer, Rachael Johnson of the Reporter’s Committee for Freedom of Press, then issued a “Writ of Certiorari” last fall in an effort to have a higher court review the case, eventually reversing the lower courts’ rulings.
Weeks ago, the Colorado Supreme Court denied Reaman and Johnson’s petition. That July 22 ruling would have been another obstacle to making this information public, but the new state law renders the CB News’ legal case moot, Reaman told the Times.
The law states that public libraries are spaces of “voluntary inquiry” that are not allowed to exclude or remove library material because of the ethnic background or gender identity of the creator, or the topics the book, movie or magazine addresses.
“The public has a right to access a range of social, political, aesthetic, moral, and other ideas and experiences through a public library,” the bill reads.
The new law states that a public library’s board of trustees must not only establish a written policy for how they acquire, display, use and remove books, but make that policy publicly available. A board’s decision on these requests for removal must also be made public. More pointedly, the law states that these requests are not considered “library user records,” and are instead open records subject to CORA.
“SB24-216 helps our library board and librarians protect the community’s freedom to read and access information without censorship,” Brookhart wrote in a statement to the Times. “Open access to public libraries is a freedom everyone should cherish, nurture and protect.”
It also states that as a public library, these institutions are obligated to challenge attempts at censorship. They’re also not allowed to prohibit materials due to partisan or “doctrinal” disapproval — doubling down that users can’t use an argument for removal that’s premised on political or religious ideas.
The legislation also adds protections for library employees and volunteers, by prohibiting retaliation against those people if they refuse to remove library materials before they’ve gone through the board’s review process.
It clarifies that challenged materials won’t be removed while being reconsidered. And, the library can’t consider challenged material more frequently than two years apart, unless the board specifies a longer period. It makes clear that the person making the request must live in the library’s legal service area.
The Gunnison County Library Board of Trustees will consider adding specific language from the law to the district’s existing policies, Brookhart wrote.
(Abby Harrison can be contacted at 970.641.1414 or abby@gunnisontimes.com.)
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here