City council approves first reading of budget ordinance

Talks city manager pay, holiday events

Posted

The Gunnison City Council approved the first reading of an ordinance adopting the 2027 city budget at its Nov. 17 work session, following a public comment and an ensuing discussion of funding and plans for town holiday events and compensation for City Manager Amanda Wilson.

The budget was previously discussed at a public hearing on Nov. 10 and at several prior city council work sessions.

Wilson opened the discussion by explaining that the ordinance would set appropriations for the various city departments while the details of the use of these funds were determined by the budget drafting process the council had engaged in.

Following a discussion of certain budget details, Councilor Loren Ahonen noted that the budget spends down the city’s general fund reserves to support various programs, with about a $3.9 million difference between revenues and expenditures.

“It’s a several year pattern and I want to note that I would like to see that pattern ending in the near future and that requires hard decisions of us and it requires hard decisions of staff,” he said.

Councilor Matt Schwartz said that he agreed and that the city may have to stop doing so in the future, although the spending is currently helping the city achieve its goals.

Mayor Diego Plata thanked resident Erik Neimeyer for providing “thoughtful and well researched,” written comments on the budget, including a variety of changes and suggestions.

Schwartz said that he recently spoke to Neimeyer and that he said he was pleased with how “helpful and responsive” staff was to his comments.

The council then heard a public comment from Cori Balch, who serves as the chair of the Gunnison County Republican Central Committee.

Balch said that she understood that Wilson’s salary, with a proposed 5 percent increase in 2027, would approach $250,000, which is more than the approximately $139,000 earned by the Colorado governor in 2027. “I recognize that these are different positions but I believe that taxpayers deserve an explanation for that difference,” she said. “What is the city manager’s exact base salary and what is the total taxpayer’s cost when we include health insurance, retirement contributions, bonuses, vehicle or travel allowances and other benefits?” Balch said. “What performance measures and comparisons with similarly sized communities justified the salary and proposed increase?”

She raised concerns about the approximately $39,000 budgeted for downtown holiday decorations, saying she had heard Western Colorado University students had offered to do the decorating, and questioned why the city was using an out-of-town contractor for the work instead of students or a local business.

Balch also raised concerns about the city using a tree within city limits for the town Christmas tree instead of potentially working with the U.S. Forest Service to locate a tree outside of town already designated for thinning.

“Finally, I ask the council to consider the bigger picture,” she said, “our families, seniors and local businesses are dealing with rising living expenses. Government should demonstrate the same financial discipline that we expect from our residents. Before approving this budget, I ask you to provide clear answers about executive compensation, discretionary spending and opportunities to reduce costs through local partnerships.”

Plata asked Wilson if she had anything to say to address Balch’s comment, which she said she was willing to do.

She said that decisions on downtown holiday lighting and the tree were based on prior council decisions.

The lighting was bid out to local contractors, and a local contractor was chosen the first year the lighting work was bid out, but they were not the low bidder the next year, and the council did not select them, Wilson said.

She said that the city continues to balance the return on investment for hiring a more expensive local company versus a less expensive outside one and that city code has rules for making these decisions.

Wilson said that a community volunteer had put up the lights in the past and, when this volunteer moved, the city tried to have its staff put up lights but “we received a lot of complaints that we weren’t doing as good of a job as the former volunteer,” which eventually led to the city seeking other options.

The city did receive an offer from Western Colorado University students to perform the service, she said, but this offer was rejected by the council over concerns about ensuring the students performed the service with sufficient quality given the impact of the lights on downtown businesses.

Wilson also said that hauling costs to bring a tree from outside of town are significant, and she and Schwartz said that the trees used for this are volunteered problem trees, not trees taken from local streets or parks.

Plata said that numerous downtown businesses have expressed appreciation for the holiday lights and their impacts on traffic in their stores.

In terms of compensation, Wilson explained that city council has adopted set of compensation guidelines, which have been in place for more than ten years.

She said Gunnison does a market analysis on every position each year to determine changes to salaries, using salary information gathered by the Colorado Municipal League. She added the council decided the city should use population, number of employees and a jurisdiction’s annual budget to determine what municipalities are comparable to Gunnison.

Wilson said that, based on these factors, Gunnison compares its salaries to 55 Colorado communities, including Crested Butte, Aspen, Glenwood Springs, Durango and Salida, and looks for the midpoint of the salary range for the communities that have a comparable position.

An analysis of publicly available documents indicates that Crested Butte approved a contract in 2025 to pay its city manager $219,350 annually, while Aspen approved an annual salary of $290,000 for its city manager in 2025. Glenwood Springs approved an annual salary of $215,000 for its city manager in 2023 and Durango approved a salary of $258,902 for its city manager in 2025. Salida approved paying its city manager $160,000 in 2023 and added the manager receiving cost of living adjustments (COLAs) to their contract in 2025.

According to Wilson, this midpoint is compared to the city’s current pay rates to determine salary adjustments, including additional adjustments to forecast how salaries might change in an upcoming year.

Wilson said, for 2027, the forecasted increase was 4.3 percent, which was more than the city could afford, which led to the city directly asking peer communities what COLA they expected to provide in 2027.

Most jurisdictions responded that their 2027 COLA was two percent, she said, which led to Gunnison also setting its increase to 2 percent, in addition to any changes from comparing current salaries to the market.

She added that salaries are also impacted by performance evaluations and the employee’s position on a scale of experience and longevity in their position, which is commonly used by local governments.

Wilson said the budget includes spending limits for positions and that the numbers for compensation in the budget do not necessarily represent what the city is paying an employee. All employees only receive increases following their annual performance evaluation, she said, and they may be paid less than the budgeted amount depending on these results.

Wage increases based on market adjustment, COLA and performance were capped at 5 percent in 2027 due to budget limitations, Wilson said, and 45 of the city’s 83 employees were indicated to receive the full 5 percent adjustment based on the survey results.

Wilson said that her 2026 salary is $235,908 and that her salary using the market study would have been adjusted to $253,067, which was more than a 5 percent increase cap, leading to the budget proposing a salary budget of $247,704.

She added that this was not a wage she proposed, since it was based on city policy, and that it was not necessarily what she would earn since her earnings would depend on her performance evaluation done by the city council and its decision following this on what she should be paid in 2027.

Wilson said that, since her hiring in 2023 and at her request, her salary has increased less than the market adjustment and has only been increased by the COLA adjustment amount.

“We have not been doing a full market analysis of the competitors, we have not been increasing for performance, not necessarily because of a lack of performance but council’s desire to ensure that our budget is responsible,” she said.

Wilson said that the risk of not making the full increase for the position is that, if she is replaced in the future, the wages could potentially be too low compared to the market to attract desirable applicants.

She said that salaries for local governments are consistently lower than those for state officials and Mayor Diego Plata added that elected officials at all levels of government, from federal to local, consistently make less money than senior staff. “It is a legacy consideration of government that your highest official in the state-like sort of system and in the federal system has this amount of money,” Plata said. “People all around them are paid salaries that are not commensurate.”

He added that there are multiple people among the 86 person staff of his employer who make more money than the Colorado governor.

“I will note that I think council has been incredibly generous with my salary and appreciate you supporting a policy that we consistently apply across our entire team,” said Wilson. “It is disappointing that we were unable to fund the compensation policy as we historically have. I will note that the changes we have applied to the whole organization still result in significant cost increases in part because of medical premiums, etc.”

Wilson added that she does not receive any bonuses, housing stipends, or fuel compensation, although she does receive and use the same medical and retirement benefits as other staff.

She said that the total personnel cost for her position, including these items, is $300,605 for 2026.

Plata said that, in the recent past, the city was also unable to hire a new city manager due to a salary that was too low relative to the market and was compelled to increase it.

The council then voted unanimously to introduce and approve on first reading the ordinance adopting the 2027 budget.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here