At its July 28 meeting, the Gunnison City Council heard a presentation from the Gunnison Country Chamber of Commerce and hospitality consulting firm HVS about a recent study of Gunnison’s hotel market.
City Manager Amanda Wilson opened the conversation by thanking Leora Wallace, executive director of the Chamber of Commerce, and the consultant team at HVS for their work on the project.
Katy Black, a managing director at HVS, began explaining that HVS is based near Denver and does a significant amount of consulting work in addition to appraisals of hotels.
She said that the study examined hotel occupancy and rate data using CoStar as well as using AirDNA to assess short term rentals.
The company also did on the ground interviews with participants in Gunnison’s lodging market, she said and performed market research for the region and on the demographics of visitors to Gunnison.
She said that the out of market visitors earn 22 to 37 percent more than locals according to data from Place AI, indicating that local demographics might be a poor indicator of the price points Gunnison’s lodging market can accommodate.
Mayor Diego Plata asked how confident Black was in the accuracy of the Placer data and how it could determine visitor demographics.
Black explained that Placer uses cell phone data to determine where visitors to the market come from and then assesses the demographics of their home area. She added that HVS does not fully rely on this data but does see it as an indicator of the market demographics.
She said data on Gunnison’s hotels was collected from six branded hotels through the CoStar platform and excluded any non-branded hotels to maintain accuracy.
This data showed that hotel occupancy rates were at 61 percent between 2021 and 2025 and that significantly increased between 2021 and 2023 and stayed “significantly high” to the present.
Black said these elevated rates show that “the rate is there” but that questions about low occupancy rates at current hotels and how a new hotel would affect this remain.
Councilor Loren Ahonen asked what a good occupancy rate is.
Black said that an occupancy rate between the high 60s and low 70s is ideal while a rate below this indicates that a location is likely a seasonal tourism destination where “the rate has to bridge the occupancy gap. So, if the rate can bridge the gap we’re okay at a lower occupancy, but that makes staffing more difficult and having these seasonal staff when you need them and not being able to employ them year round because your off-season is slow can be really challenging from an operational perspective too.”
Black also shared data from AirDNA which showed overall that available short-term rental units in the summer are “doing very well” with the average rate sitting at about $250 per night year round and supply steady over the last three years.
She explained that this data from AirDNA should be “taken with a grain of salt” since it only documents short term rentals that are available to rent when considering rates and that the data considers an area around Gunnison, not just rentals located in the city limits.
Black said that the study compared performance in Gunnison with Salida and Montrose, which found that all the towns had similar occupancy rates across months and that Salida and Gunnison were aligned on average rates while average rates in Montrose were about $20 higher.
The study compared the side by side performance metrics for similar hotels in the three locations to further analyze the data, Black said.
She explained that it also involved a feasibility analysis for several types of potential hotels in Gunnison, comparing their cost to build to estimated value to help determine what type of hotel development might be feasible.
She said that this analysis found that an “upper midscale extended stay” hotel similar to Hilton’s Home2 Suites hotels would be the most viable in Gunnison.
In response to a question from Ahonen, Black explained that there is not strong evidence of strong extended stay demand in Gunnison but that this finding was based on travelers being more willing to pay more for the extended stay experience with a kitchenette and other amenities, even if they do not stay for an extended period of time.
She added that she has also seen strong interest in developing similar hotels in places like Montrose or elsewhere in rural Colorado.
Black said that the study found development of a downtown boutique motel would be unlikely to be financially feasible due Gunnison’s downtown not being mature enough but that a glamping focused lodging destination could be highly successful.
Gunnison’s occupancy tax rates are below those in comparable towns or resort locations in Colorado.
Mayor Pro Tem Marisela Ballesteros asked if the study was able to gain any data from locally owned hotels that do not report data on CoStar and had any recommendations about how they could improve.
HVS Consulting and Valuation Senior Associate George Stathakes explained that he visited these locally owned locations while doing research in Gunnison, finding that there were a range of hotels that were performing well and poorly.
However, he said that his research was not focused on what could benefit them and more centered on gathering data about their occupancy rates, clientele, rates and other information.
City Manager Wilson said that, while the data collected in the study was primarily focused on new construction of hotels, existing hotels could potentially use it to reorient their operations or add features and facilities to attract the unaccommodated portions of the market identified in the report.
“So, to George’s point, they weren’t looking to necessarily solve how the city could support some of these businesses but, in and of itself, this report was absolutely intended to empower those existing businesses with information,” Wilson said.
Wallace at the Chamber of Commerce confirmed that this was an accurate portrayal of the study’s goals.
Wilson added that this was also a focus of the Chamber of Commerce board.
“As you are aware, some of those board members are also in the lodging industry and recognize that information is power and that we are, in fact, helping,” she said.
“Thank you for the comprehensive overview,” Plata said. “Some of this information was kind of surprising. Not good or bad but it was interesting to read through so thanks for all of the work pulling it together. George, Katy, Leora, thanks for leading this on. We appreciate the partnership and we hope to use this data for future conversations as we move forward.”
Stathakes closed the discussion by thanking city staff and local hotels.
“Everybody that I interviewed was just so incredibly helpful and open and warm and informative,” he said. “I just wanted to thank everybody for that on the record too.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here