The risk of water curtailments throughout the state is growing as the Upper and Lower basin states continue to negotiate a way to deal with extensive drought conditions along the Colorado River — a system under significant stress as the West dries up.
On Sept. 27, the City of Gunnison’s water attorney, Jennifer DiLalla, provided council with an update on the standings of its water rights. She focused on the city’s preparedness to maintain water security as Colorado discusses how it will handle a potential “compact call,” which could reduce the water supply of more junior users throughout the state. The Colorado River Compact is a 1922 agreement allocating water use rights between basin states.
While the Lower Basin states of Nevada, Arizona and California are already dealing with compact-related reductions to their water use to boost the levels of Lake Powell, the Upper Basin states of Colorado, Wyoming, Utah and New Mexico, have not yet been faced with a compact call. A call would result from the Upper Basin’s inability to meet its delivery obligations to the Lower Basin, requiring water cuts upstream to make up for the deficit.
Water planners in Colorado evaluate their portfolios based on whether the water rights that make up their water supply are junior or senior to the compact. Because the state has never issued a compact call, DiLalla said it is unclear how the stand intends to handle junior water rights.
She said it is safe to assume the compact will be treated as water right with a 1922 priority, which means the state division of engineers would begin cutting off diversions in reverse order of priority.
“The more junior you are, the more likely you are to get curtailed,” DiLalla said.
According to DiLalla, the city is well positioned based on the pre-compact priorities of its “workhorse” water rights. The town ditch, which is one of the city’s primary water sources, is decreed for 64 cubic feet per second (cfs) out of the Gunnison River — which accounts for almost 42 million gallons per day — with an 1880 priority date. For the 10-year period between 2012 and 2022, the ditch was never out of priority. While it can only be utilized between May and September, the water can be stored and is critical for long-term planning, she said.
The town pipeline, another significant diversion, has an 1883 appropriation and priority date with no seasonal limits — making it available for municipal use when the ditch isn’t running.
When planning for future growth, the city acquired several productive pre-compact water rights that will be used for the Gunnison Rising annexation. Each of these water rights has a priority date before 1900 and is budgeted specifically for the new development.
Despite what DiLalla called a “strong and resilient” portfolio, she still recommended that city staff draft risk mitigation strategies to protect against severe and long-term drought, events that could ultimately trigger a compact call along the Colorado. Storage will be critical, she said.
The city is entitled to store almost 3,000 acre-feet per year, which is just shy of 1 trillion gallons of water. Under its decree, the city would be able to store this water in “reservoir #4,” a 3,000 acre-foot structure near Antelope Creek. As part of this right, other small ponds scattered around the city including the city-owned Van Tuyl Ranch, could serve as alternate points of storage.
None of these structures have been built yet. The city is only presently able to store water in 2.2 million gallon storage tanks on the hill behind Western Colorado University.
DiLalla and her team will also begin to develop water supply metrics, a tool the city is trying to interconnect with its soon-to-be-updated 3 mile plan. The new metrics will serve as an objective tool to show where the city has “capacity in terms of water,” said City Manager Russ Forrest.
“We don't want to just assume that we're good in drought years,” Public Works Director David Gardner told the Times. “We want to conserve our water.”
Looking beyond the city
That same week, Erin Wilson, an engineer with the water supply planning group, Wilson Water, gave the Upper Gunnison River Water Conservancy District board an overview of the basin’s compact risk.
Wilson began by reminding board members that the hydrology of the Gunnison River is extremely variable — with streamflows fluctuating significantly depending on year’s snowpack and summer monsoonal rains. She used 2018 and 2019 water years as an example. In 2019, a wet year for the Gunnison Basin, streamflow was three times higher than the dry year of 2018.
“This variability is part of our struggle with everything, including compacts,” Wilson said.
Since 2000, the Gunnison River has experienced more dry years than any other 22-year period since measurements began in 1908. Warming temperatures and reduced precipitation would influence different changes upstream at each of the Gunnison River’s four main tributaries: Ohio Creek, the Taylor River, the East River and Tomichi Creek, she said.
Along the East River, early runoff will likely reduce the period of optimum recreational flows for boaters — increasing competition between agricultural water users and recreationalists. But overall, depletions are relatively small compared to the river’s natural flow — the yield of a water body if communities stopped consuming water — ranging from 5-17%, she said.
In comparison, depletions along Ohio Creek, where a significant portion of runoff is diverted for irrigation, can stretch between 30-50% of the creek’s natural flow. Many of these ditches experience shortages late in the irrigation season, regardless of whether it is a wet or dry year. Speeded runoff will only further limit water availability for ranchers, Wilson said.
“There could be increased issues between agricultural users and anglers,” she said. “Even though this is a primary irrigation basin, there is a lot of other uses on the river.”
John McClow, general counsel for the Upper Gunnison, said there is a glimmer of hope with the renegotiation of the 2007 guidelines — a set of rules that coordinated the operations of Lake Powell and Lake Mead by identifying the conditions that would trigger shortages within the Lower Basin states.
“The problem is not the Colorado River Compact, the problem is aridification,” McClow said. “Water is going to be less no matter what. The question is, how do we deal with it? And who is going to pay the price?”
(Bella Biondini can be contacted at 970.641.1414 or bella@gunnisontimes.com.)
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here