
The second thing President Donald Trump’s new chairman of the Federal Trade Commission, Andrew Ferguson, did on assuming his duties was to withdraw requests for public comments on FTC information-gathering dockets about corporate “surveillance pricing” online. “Predatory pricing,” and other shady tactics had been a focus of the Commission under Biden’s chairwoman Lina Khan, who initiated the requests for comments to gather information.
“Surveillance pricing” is a process whereby, in a nanosecond or two, your incoming order is weighed in light of everything they know about you: your zipcode neighborhood, the phone you’re calling in on and the raft of other data being piled up in servers on all of us in corporate headquarters around the — well, the world.
And depending on that data from this surveillance, the price you are invoiced may be a little more than you saw on the website. Not much, but great fortunes are built on lots of pennies here and there. In the 29 comments that came in before the request was withdrawn, Amazon was mentioned, as were grocery chains and VRBO sites.
“Predatory pricing” is the phenomenon people experience most often in trying to buy airline tickets whose prices won’t stay still, especially in a situation with several thousand people stranded in an airport in a storm. (More about the FTC on these issues at regulations.gov/docket/FTC-2025-0011.)
This is the Federal Trade Commission under a president who was elected on a promise to lower grocery prices. But given the front-row presence at the inauguration of America’s grocer-in-chief, Jeff Bezos, we can imagine that he is closer to the president’s ear than any of his customers will ever be, as to what’s best for grocery pricing.
There are two ways to address such practices. One is to write our congressman and senators, the president, and all the other ways they recommend for citizen input, and tell them to stop treating us like we're nothing but exploitable consumers. Do it if you’re so inclined.
But another way (which doesn’t preclude the first) is to forego the convenience of one-click shopping and buy local when you can. We vote with our dollars as well as our ballots, and our choices, dollar by dollar, will either be voting for stronger valley communities or voting for a stronger corporate culture out there.
To be sure, there are things we need, or just want that we can’t get locally, and somebody out there will have it. And some local places are less “local” than others — chains, franchises.
But even then – buying local pays some local wages and taxes. And you might run into someone you know, or meet someone you didn’t.
But given what’s going on at the Federal Trade Commission, it is also a vote for where we are, who we are, against political-economic powers to whom we are just data to be profitably manipulated.
(George Sibley is a Gunnison writer, thinker and elder of the headwaters.)
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here