
Everyone in the valleys of the Upper Gunnison River watersheds who love our rivers and streams probably has a favorite place for seeing the work of the Upper Gunnison River Water Conservancy District — although we might not know that is what we are seeing.
One of my favorite places for this is in the Gunnison Whitewater Park at the first manmade “rapid” for recreational boaters. The District worked with Gunnison County to put that project together, and acquired the 2003 “recreational in-stream” water right for the park.
That first rapid, however, was created where it is in order to raise the level of the river to the headgate for the “75 Ditch.” The ditch, diverted in 1875 to irrigate Alonzo Hartman’s ranch, has the oldest water right in the entire Gunnison River Basin. This means the oldest water right in the valley is linked constructively with one of the newest. Between them lies the valley’s ever-changing history, including the 65-year history of the water district.
The mission of the District is “to be an active leader in all issues affecting the water resources of the Upper Gunnison River Basin.” The District has done this in creative, but often subtle ways like the example above, helping carry our past forward into our emerging future.
Consider the Taylor River: as beautiful a mountain stream as you will find anywhere. Iit looks and runs like a natural river today thanks to the District. In the 1930s, the U.S. Bureau of Reclamation built the Taylor Dam high on the river to store late-season water for down stream irrigators in the Uncompahgre River Valley. This effectively shut off the river in the spring. It turned it into an irrigation canal the rest of the year, “killing” the natural river cycle and a world-class fishery.
Reclamation came back in the 1950s to build the Blue Mesa, Morrow Point and Crystal dams west of Gunnison as part of the massive regional Colorado River Storage Project — reservoirs that drowned the towns of Iola and Sapinero, and killed another, and even more beloved, fishery. Many Upper Gunnison people were not happy with Reclamation in those decades.
To make amends, Reclamation proposed an Upper Gunnison River Project, a set of small reservoirs and canals for local use. The District was created in 1959 to work with Reclamation in bringing that project into being.
Reclamation also promised to “subordinate,” for later development above the dams, the rights to 60,000 acre-feet of the water it would have storage rights for in the Aspinall Unit reservoirs. It also promised to purchase or replace the fisheries it was inundating.
But by the time the three dams we know as the Wayne N. Aspinall Unit were completed in the 1970s, the nation had ceased to invest heavily in western water development, and the Upper Gunnison River Project was abandoned.
Rather than folding, the District began to take on other challenges and opportunities. One of these was resurrecting the Taylor River. Once Blue Mesa Dam was completed, District Attorney Richard Bratton worked with Reclamation, arguing that it would make sense to store the Uncompahgre Valley irrigators’ water from Taylor Reservoir in Blue Mesa, at least a day’s flow closer to the Gunnison Tunnel.
That meant the Uncompahgre water could be moved from Taylor on the seasonal schedule of a natural river. Following the 1975 agreement, the District has convened a “Taylor Local Users Group” of irrigators, rafters, fishermen and Taylor property owners every spring to advise Reclamation on how best to operate reservoir releases to meet local needs.
The District didn’t stop there. The Continental Divide mountains above Taylor Park produced more water than the 106,000 acre-feet captured for the Uncompahgre Valley water users — water coveted by Front Range cities. Soon after the agreement, with the Taylor Reservoir technically “empty” after the Uncompahgre water was moved to Blue Mesa, the District filed on Taylor Park water for a second fill of the reservoir. The water would be used for the fishery, wildlife and other environmental needs as well as supplemental irrigation water.
This unusual request was adjudicated in 1990, and not a moment too soon. In 1986, the City of Aurora filed a claim for a transmountain diversion, the Collegiate Range-Aurora Project. It would pump water up to Taylor Reservoir from a new reservoir near the junction of the East and Taylor rivers (flooding Almont), and through a tunnel to the Front Range.
Then in 1988 the Natural Energy Resources Company (NECO), a conspiracy of retired Reclamation engineers, filed a much more elaborate plan for a large reservoir in Union Park. It would be filled by pumping water up from Taylor Reservoir, with unappropriated water gathered from all over the Upper Gunnison tributaries. It would also be moved through a tunnel to the Front Range.
In 1988, NECO sold this seemingly fantastic idea to Arapahoe County, pending the granting of all the water rights that NECO had filed on. Aurora abandoned its even more fantastic plan to join Arapahoe.
The Division Four water court became the battleground, and the District went into “protect and defend” mode. Attorneys Bratton and his partner, John McClow, rallied an army of Western Slope water organizations and friends of the court, including Reclamation, against the phalanx of Arapahoe attorneys and engineers. It turned out to be an epic battle over the future of Colorado River water.
The NECO plan finally died an expensive death in 2001, after multiple appeals to the Colorado Supreme Court from Arapahoe County. It was expensive for the winners too. The District asked the taxpayers to double their mill levy — a request readily granted. No major Front Range transmountain diversion efforts have materialized since.
Before that was completed, District water users were threatened by two complex challenges from downstream. One was a “federal reserved water right” for the Black Canyon of the Gunnison National Park. The other was a shared responsibility for the fate of four endangered Colorado River fish species found in the Lower Gunnison Basin.
According to U.S. Supreme Court decisions, when the government reserved public lands for any specific purpose, like a National Park, it implicitly also reserved enough water to carry out that purpose. The National Park Service was charged with “conserving unimpaired” for “this and future generations” some “natural and cultural resource” — in the case of the Black Canyon, a magnificent geological feature and the wild river that was gouging it out.
Then in the 1960s and 70s, another Department of the Interior branch of the federal government built three major dams upstream from the Black Canyon that seriously “impaired” the natural conditions of the canyon and its river.
In the 1970s, the Park Service had applied for, and been given, an unquantified water right for the former National Monument with a 1933 appropriation date. Finally, in 2001, the other shoe dropped. The Park Service applied for a quantification that required a spring flood to purge the canyon of its greenery (dominated by poison ivy) and restore its cutting function. Spring was also the time for water storage.
All hell broke loose, both upstream in the District where many users would be junior to the 1933 decree, and downstream where the absence of spring floods had been considered a blessing. Nearly 400 statements were filed in opposition to the plan by the time the dust settled.
After six years of litigation and some political wrangling, a mediator was hired. In December 2008, a decree went to water court that gave the Park Service a spring flood based on the Upper Gunnison runoff. It would also prevent downstream flooding and not interfere with existing junior water rights in the Upper Gunnison Basin.
The endangered fish plan was not so difficult to resolve, and has been settled with an “Aspinall Unit Reoperation” of increased spring flows overlapping somewhat with the Black Canyon water right releases. Blue Mesa Reservoir storage was somewhat affected, but with little or no harm to water users.
The District has also shown creative leadership in water development. After the state engineer declared the Gunnison River over-appropriated (unable to fill all water rights) in the exceptionally dry water year 2002, state law required anyone wanting a new surface or groundwater right from the river and its tributaries to file an “augmentation plan.”
This demonstrated the capability, in the event of a downstream call, of replacing the water they were withdrawing from the river system from some other source. In response, the District leased 500 acre-feet in Blue Mesa to provide augmentation water for certain areas in the valley. The District created a “new source” by raising the outlet works on Meridian Lake above Crested Butte several feet to support new builds in the Crested Butte area.
At this point, the era of water development of the Colorado River and its Gunnison tributary is probably mostly completed. The District has joined the rest of the state in planning processes for the unknowns of changing climate, diminishing waters and population growth. This short overview shows only the diverse breadth and often subtle quality of the work of the organization that has creatively and consistently worked for 65 years to develop, protect and defend the water resources of the Upper Gunnison River and its mountain tributaries.
(George Sibley is a Gunnison writer, thinker and elder of the headwaters.)
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here