
The Gunnison City Council discussed the 25 miles of city irrigation ditches at a recent work session for next year’s budget. To the best of my knowledge, this has never really been brought up as a debatable budgetary item. Certainly it has never been brought into the public discourse in the time I’ve been here.
I’ll begin by saying that I love the city ditch system, and our household is a pretty heavy ditch user. Our plants love the ditch water more than they love the treated city water. And it’s “free!” We have to pay for the electricity to get it out of the ditch and onto our seven garden areas and the lawn around and between them, but there is no charge for the water itself. It’s kind of like having a natural stream that runs down the street, into which we can drop a pump intake and keep our green stuff growing and happy.
But it is not a natural stream, of course. The ditch system was built by foresighted early settlers when the city was still just a platted sprinkling of buildings in a barren sagebrush and bunch-grass desert. We’ve all seen that picture of early Gunnison.
That we can call ourselves a “Tree City” these days is a testament to their foresight. Their hard work, through time, maintained by the city Public Works crews, has made life in the high desert a lot more tolerable. The ditches are part of the character and heritage of the community — part of what makes Gunnison, Gunnison.
But now, while I haven’t heard or seen any numbers on the matter, the ditch system appears to be in trouble. Word has it that the headgate on the Gunnison River is in really bad shape. Even though cleaning and maintenance of the ditches has increasingly been turned over to those of us who use the ditches, there is still a lot of infrastructure maintenance that — like most of the infrastructure of America today — has been neglected by those of us who take it for granted. Getting the ditches back in shape will cost money that we all will, of course, feel we can ill afford.
There is another problem about the ditch that no one ever talks about, and I’ll probably be cussed for bringing it up. The ditch system is inequitable. The ditches do not deliver water to everyone in the City of Gunnison, but everyone in the city pays for the time and energy the public works guys have to put in on them.
Those of us who use the ditches enjoy what seems to be “free water,” and it is easy to slip into feeling it is some kind of an entitlement. But we are essentially being subsidized by the rest of the community, and that is not right.
I would guess that the new city council is going to have to face up to this long-ignored issue, and the discourse will probably not be pretty — just as the discourse about the streets and alleys has not been pretty. Taking an “environmental impact study” kind of approach to it, there seem to me to be three alternative solutions.
The first is the standard EIS “No Action” alternative: continue muddling along as we have, patching and repairing the headgate and conveyance structures out of the general Public Works budget — making it more clear to ditch users that they are responsible for the ditches in their own neighborhood. People without ditches haven’t been complaining about subsidizing that part of the character and quality of the community, so don’t worry about the inequity.
The second, and easiest, “action” solution would be to just abandon the ditch system and sell the very senior water rights or divert the water to the new municipal water plant.
The third, and most difficult, alternative would be for those of us who use the ditches to work with city council and Public Works to figure out what it will cost annually to repair, maintain and operate the ditch system, calculate a per-user fee to meet most of that expense and see if it would be affordable for users to pay for the use of their water. The city should still be taking a share of the cost, since city property extends about a third of the way into everyone’s front yard and includes the city trees that drink from the ditches.
There would be no way to meter the use of the water, but a flat fee could be levied on everyone who drops a pump hose into the ditches. I have no idea at this point how many of us there are, and what the costs are that would have to be covered; it might be simply unaffordable — cheaper to use treated city water. In which case, either the “No Action” alternative or the abandonment alternative are the options.
I can already hear the complaints about a ditch fee (and will probably get some angry calls reiterating them). Some people will be accused of using more water than their fair share. Some people with no pump will have trees in their yard that obviously tap into the ditch. People with graveled xeriscapes they can water from a watering can might prefer no ditch at all in front of their house.
Nothing is easy. But there’s a rumbling from the “old council” that this has to be on the table in some way for the next budget, in which the Council will be trying to figure out how to shoehorn in a new, and much overdue, water treatment facility. It’s another can, like streets and alleys, that we can’t kick down the road forever. But I hope we can come up with a way to maintain this part of who we are.
(George Sibley is a Gunnison writer, thinker and elder of the headwaters.)
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here